Chicago’s Aleksandar Katai  celebrates his second goal as NYCFC defender Alexander Callens lools on. (Mike DiNovo-USA TODAY Sports)

BRIDGEWATER, Ill. — After overcoming an early deficit, New York City FC could not hold onto the lead, allowing the Chicago Fire to score a 3-2 MLS victory at Toyota Park Saturday night.

Aleksandar Katai struck twice within a five-minute span early in the second half as the Fire overcame a 2-1 deficit.

Domenec Torrent, who won in his league debut last week, tasted defeat for the first time as City head coach.

Two minutes into the second half, Katai knotted things up at 2-2 as he had his way with left back Ben Sweat before he putting his shot to the far post. In the 52nd minute, Katai was at it again, this time bewildering two defenders in Sweat and Alex Callens for a 3-2 lead with his eighth goal this season.

Chicago (6-7-5, 23 points) grabbed a 1-0 lead six minutes into the match. Former Red Bulls captain Dax McCarty sent a through ball to Nemanja Nikolic, who slipped a low shot inside the far post from just inside the box past goalkeeper Sean Johnson.

NYCFC (9-4-4) equalized in the 36th minute on Ismael Tajouri-Shradi’s eighth goal of the year. He fired his left-footed shot off the hand of goalkeeper Richard Sanchez inside the far post.

In the 40th minute, Jo Inge Berget gave the visitors a 2-1 lead with his third goal in the last two games. Anton Tinnerholm served a ball inside the penalty area in which Berget snapped a header home from 16 yards.

Berget almost added a second goal in the 73rd minute as he headed the ball off the crossbar.

NYCFC captain and striker David Villa missed the game with a knee injury. It was not known how long he will be sidelined.

SCORING SUMMARY

6’ – CHI – Nemanja Nikolic (Assisted by: Dax McCarty)

36’ – NYC – Ismael Tajouri-Shradi (Assisted by: Maxi Moralez)

40’ – NYC – Jo Inge Berget (Assisted by: Anton Tinnerholm)

47’ – CHI – Aleksandar Katai (Assisted by: Dax McCarty)

52’ – CHI – Aleksandar Katai (Assisted by: Elliot Collier)

DISCIPLINE SUMMARY

10’ – CHI –Brandt Bronico (YC – Unsporting Behavior)

28’ – NYC – Alexander Ring (YC – Unsporting Behavior)

89’ – CHI – Richard Sanchez (YC – Time Wasting)

91’ – CHI – Alan Gordon (YC – Unsporting Behavior)

LINEUPS

Chicago Fire: Richard Sanchez, Jorge Corrales, Brandon Vincent, Jonathan Campbell, Diego Campos; Bastian Schweinsteiger (85’ Tony Tchani), Dax McCarty, Bronico; Elliot Collier (66’ Mohammed Adams), Nemanja Nikolic (72’ Alan Gordon), Aleksandar Katai

SUBS UNUSED: Stefan Cleveland, Christian Dean, Rafael Ramos, Jon Bakero

New York City FC: Sean Johnson; Ben Sweat (75’ Jonathan Lewis), Sebastien Ibeagha, Alexander Callens, Anton Tinnerholm; Maxi Moralez, Alexander Ring, Ebenezer Ofori; Ismael Tajouri-Shradi, Jo Inge Berget, Jesus Medina (92’ Tommy McNamara)

SUBS UNUSED: Brad Stuver, Maxime Chanot, Saad Abdul-Salaam, Kwame Awuah, James Sands